When Briony Martha bumped into James McAvoy at a Costa Coffee on Sauchiehall Street in Glasgow, it was the kind of random encounter most of us would dine out on for years. A chance meeting with a Scottish superstar—the same actor who appeared in Cyrano de Bergerac at the Theatre Royal in Glasgow during the mask-wearing spring of 2022. But Martha's new play, Parasocial Activity, running at Òran Mór in Glasgow until 21 November before moving to Southwark Playhouse in London from 13-30 January, asks a chilling question: what happens when that innocent moment becomes fuel for an elaborate digital fantasy?
In Martha's production, directed by Megan Brewer, the protagonist Jenny—played by Martha herself in a pink jumpsuit and Hello Kitty T-shirt—takes that coffee shop encounter and spins it into something far more sinister. McAvoy gave her two tickets to his show. A generous gesture, surely. But Jenny's mind transforms it into proof of romantic interest. The tickets become a love letter. The coffee becomes a date. And then come the messages—courtesy of generative AI, they're indistinguishable from the real thing.
Here's where Martha's play becomes genuinely unsettling. In another era, Jenny's fantasy would have remained harmless, a private delusion that hurt no one. But technology has rewritten that equation. When AI can generate text that sounds exactly like James McAvoy, when it can sustain an entire relationship that only exists in ones and zeros, the line between innocent daydreaming and genuine psychosis dissolves. McAvoy was actually in the audience during the Edinburgh Fringe run this summer—imagine the surreal reality of watching your delusion played out while the person you're obsessing over watches from the stalls.
The genius of Megan Brewer's production is making us complicit. As Martha performs with wide-eyed energy, we find ourselves rooting for the fantasy too. We want the rags-to-riches love story to be real. We want McAvoy to have followed her on Instagram, to have posed for that picture at the stage door, to have sent those affirming messages. The delusion becomes as convincing to us as it is to Jenny. And by the time the interaction spirals into what the play calls 'AI psychosis,' we've drifted alongside her to the wrong side of the truth/lies divide.
Martha has created something urgent and deeply uncomfortable—a play that reminds us that knowing what to believe really is getting harder. Technology has blurred every line. And generative AI has handed us the perfect tool for sustaining whatever fantasy we choose to believe. After seeing Parasocial Activity, that random encounter in a coffee shop will never look innocent again.